Enjoy a 4.7-rated stay at School House Inn in Altmar, NY. Rustic lodge with free Wi-Fi, free parking, terrace, fire pit, near Salmon River Falls and Selkirk Shores Park.
Guests value the down-to-earth accommodations, personalized service, and prime location near Salmon River and local outdoor activities. Practical amenities and a welcoming atmosphere make this a favored spot for fishing enthusiasts and visitors seeking a simple, relaxing stay.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Set on leafy grounds near the Salmon River, this rustic lodge offers straightforward accommodations with a focus on practicality. Guests can enjoy free Wi-Fi, complimentary parking, and a terrace featuring a fire pit, providing a relaxed outdoor setting. The rooms are simple yet clean, equipped with basic amenities such as a microwave, mini refrigerator, and cable television, making it ideal for visitors seeking a no-frills stay.
Located just off State Route 13 in Altmar, New York, the inn is conveniently situated within walking distance of town and close to popular fishing spots along the Salmon River. It is approximately 6 miles from Salmon River Falls and 14 miles from Oswego County Nature Park, offering several nearby outdoor activities including fishing, kayaking, and snowmobiling. Selkirk Shores State Park is also nearby, providing lakeside camping and multi-use trails with scenic sunset views.
The property tends to attract anglers and outdoor enthusiasts who value access to quality fishing locations and a comfortable base without unnecessary luxury. Many guests have praised the friendly and hospitable innkeepers, as well as the fishing guide services connected to the inn. The relaxed atmosphere and proximity to the river make it a practical choice for those focused on fishing and nature exploration.
While the inn does not offer on-site dining, fitness facilities, or a pool, the simplicity aligns well with the needs of visitors planning to spend time outdoors. Reviews highlight the dependable cleanliness of the rooms and the helpfulness of the staff, contributing to repeat visits from those familiar with the area. The welcoming environment and straightforward accommodations create a setting well-suited for travelers seeking a grounded, practical place to stay.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Rib smokes the best fish! All fish are flavored well with many choices of flavors. All are packaged neatly for travel and storage
Stayed here between July 5th-12th for a graduation party, was the best place to stay during the week since they lived 12 minutes away.
Been staying at Rob's place for a long time, always been great for me, and great location for the upper part of the river.
Rob is a great Inn keeper and his smoked salmon is to die for! Great place to stay walking distance to Altmar, Ny
Great place to stay. This is our third time and everytime has been enjoyable. Rob is a great person and even came to our rescue when we had truck problems.
In my mind this is a perfect spot to stay and fish the Salmon River. It is within walking distance of the lower fly fishing section and plenty of other great spots. Get in the truck and you can fish all the other holes on the river. The rooms are not fancy which is perfect for me. At the end of the day of fishing all you need is a warm room, and maybe a place to tie some flies and a bed to sleep in! I stayed in room number 2. A smaller room but there were only two of us and worked out nicely. Our room did have a small fridge, a microwave, and a coffee maker with coffee, sugar and powdered creamer. Cable TV with spotty Wi-Fi but that's okay you're not there for that! You are there for the world-class fishery that it is! Keep in mind when booking in the area, a lot of places do not supply Linens, the schoolhouse in does supply all of your Linens! Enjoy your trip! Fish on ! Thanks Rob for a great stay!
I've stayed at the schoolhouse inn for 2 seasons. The rooms are nice and clean. There is a microwave, mini refrigerator and cable television in the rooms. Bunk beds if you want to room with friends. They give you your own personalized parking space. You can get WI-Fi at the house. From the Inn you can snowmobile, kayak or fish the Salmon. The owners, Phil and Renee, are some of the most hospitable and friendly people you will meet. They also run a guide service and take people on Salmon and other western NY tribs. I've seen some pics of their guided trips and trust me they are landing some hefty browns. I met one of the guides who works for Phil, Phinbar, and he makes some great flies. He also has an outgoing personality for guiding folks and ties excellent flies. If you are nice to him, he might sell you a box of his top patterns at a great price. Overall, you can't go wrong staying at the Schoolhouse Inn or hiring Phil and his crew to guide you on your fishing expedition.
I have been fishing up there for years as staying here. It's changed owners last year but new owners are friends with old owners who were fishing friends of mine. They are all good people. The fishing guide they have Fibur is the best. Im the owner of God'z Rod'z and Reel'z and I recomend this lodge for your stay and Fibur for your fishing guide service. In 2015 I landed the largest steelhead in New York and the school house is where stayed!
Set on leafy grounds just off the Salmon River, this rustic lodge is 6 miles from Salmon River Falls and 14 miles from Oswego County Nature Park. It's just off State Route 13.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
1,265 reviews 7101 State Rte 3, Pulaski, NY 13142, United States
334 reviews Orwell, NY 13302, United States
865 reviews 185 Falls Rd, Richland, NY 13144, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Budget Inn offers free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms in Yreka, CA. Rated 3.5 stars with 180 reviews, ideal for sightseein...
Stay at Thunderbird Motel in Missoula, MT. Enjoy free WiFi, indoor pool, petfriendly rooms, and close access to Caras Park and M...
Affordable 2.6rated motel with 26 reviews at 301 E Danker St, Knox. Close to Tippecanoe River State Park and Hoosier Valley Railr...
Stay at Taylor Motel, a 3.1star motel in Mobile, AL offering free WiFi and parking. Near USS ALABAMA Battleship Memorial Park an...
4star Days Inn & Suites by Wyndham Huntsville offers free WiFi, breakfast, pool, and parking. Close to Sam Houston State Univers...
Stay at Wyndham Garden Anchorage Airport with free WiFi, breakfast, and shuttle. Close to Ted Stevens Anchorage Airport and popul...
Stay at Aladdin Motel, a 4.3rated pet and kidfriendly motel in Aladdin, WY. Close to Aladdin Coal Tipple and Vore Buffalo Jump ...
Budget Host Motel in Botkins, OH offers airconditioned, kidfriendly rooms with breakfast. Close to Armstrong Air & Space Museum ...
Stay at Compass by Margaritaville Hotel in Pigeon Forge, TN. Enjoy free WiFi, pools, petfriendly rooms, and close access to Doll...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
